Dear Appeals Committee:
I have encountered serious ongoing academic issues with Professor Patricia Simmons and her method of instruction for the Humanities: The Modern Period (Hum 306) in the Spring term and I would like to contest my final grade. Due to miscommunication and unprofessional practices, I was required to accept an Incomplete until last week. On Monday I learned that I was awarded a C-.
Throughout my academic career I have worked hard for grades that never fell below a B. This C- is an insult to my hard work. Prof. Simmon’s teaching methods fell far below the standard set by the Humanities department. I am used to professors with specific insight and instructional knowledge. I am not accustomed to someone who teaches directly out of the book and assigns at least half a class, all semester, to student presentations. In effect, the students taught half of the class from random subjects mentioned in the Humanities textbook.
I attempted to construct a successful senior thesis without any guidance from Prof. Simmons. Although I appreciated being awarded extra time to wrap up my Senior project, I felt hamstrung by her lack of support. I finished my thesis feeling cheated and unsure.
In addition, both the midterm and final exams tested on obtuse, and often, unfamiliar information. I remain ignorant as to the grade on my final exam. Technically I failed the midterm, but due to the overwhelmingly poor scores in the class, Prof. Simmons instituted an 18 point curve. That brought my grade up to a C-. I thought that I could pull the grade up with my final exam and paper. That was a false hope.
I would like to opportunity to have my grade re-evaluated. I do not believe that I was given a chance to succeed in Prof. Simmon’s class.
If you require any additional assistance in this matter, please feel free to contact me.
Thank you for your time.








August 10th, 2006 at 1:29 pm
Very well-written. I have written a few appeals lately (in regards to a language credit - which I, as an English masters student, should not need) and I think this is great. I wish you luck in this endeavor.
August 10th, 2006 at 1:32 pm
well written my dear! keep me posted
August 10th, 2006 at 4:58 pm
yes, nicely put. I Hope all works out for you.